FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATTION OF LIVING PERSONS IN CASES OF INJURY OF THE ORGANS OF EXTERNAL RESPIRATION
PDF

Keywords

forensic medical examination, trauma of external respiratory organs, diagnostic criteria, severity of bodily injuries

Abstract

Backrgound. Trauma of external respiratory organs in victims is often a reason for the referral to forensic medical examination by law enforcement.

Purpose of this work was to analyze the peculiarities of formation forensic medical expert conclusion, based on the results of determining the gravity of bodily injuries in victims with closed trauma of the organs external respiration, depending on their morphological and clinical characteristics and gravity, to find the ways to unify expert assessment.

Subjects and Methods. 183 conclusions of forensic medical examination in the Kharkiv regional expert institution, on the cases of a closed blunt trauma of the organs of external respiration, were analyzed.

Results. According to the mechanism of bodily injuries, in 171,1 (93,4 %) cases there was an impact of blunt solid objects on the neck and chest, in 11 (6 %) cases there was a compression of the neck by hands or other blunt solid objects, in 1 (0,5 %) case – a compression of the neck by hands and a loop. At the given trauma, modern experts’ approaches to an assessment of bodily injuries were defined. Grievous bodily injuries were defined in 17 (9,3 %) cases of trauma, with the emergence of life-threatening events such as acute respiratory failure, traumatic shock, mechanical asphyxia. Moderate bodily injuries were determined by experts in the 151 (82,5 %) cases, mostly injuries from fractures of ribs and cartilage of the larynx, at absence danger to life. Light bodily injuries were determined by experts in 15 (8,2 %) cases of mostly laryngeal injuries, complicated by its post-traumatic inflammation. The absence of unified scientific and methodological approach for the objective assessment of injuries of the external respiratory system organs has been defined.

Conclusions. When conducting a forensic medical assessment of such injuries, there are cases of both underestimation and overestimation of the gravity of bodily injuries. According to the results of the performed investigation, further ways to unify morphological and clinical approaches at forensic-medical assessment of these bodily injuries were defined. 

https://doi.org/10.35339/ic.8.2.95-99
PDF

References

Mykhailychenko BV, Kikinchuk VV, Peshenko OM. (2020) Sudova ekspertolohiia (sudova medytsyna): navchalnyi posibnyk [Forensic medical expertise (forensic medicine): a textbook]. Kyiv, Kharkiv: «Vydavnytstvo Liudmyla». 396 s. [in Ukrainian].

Pravyla sudovo-medychnoho vyznachennia stupenia tiazhkosti tilesnykh ushkodzhen [Rules for forensic medical assessment of bodily injuries severity]. Nakaz MOZ Ukrainy №6 vid 17.01.1995 r. "Pro rozvytok ta vdoskonalennia sudovo-medychnoi sluzhby Ukrainy". Kyiv, 1995; 220 s. [in Ukrainian].

Holubovych LL, Olkhovskyi VO, Herasymenko OI. (2021) Osnovy sudovoi medytsyny: navchalno-metodychnyi posibnyk [Bases of forensic medicine: Textbook]. Kharkiv: FOP Brovin O.V. 536 s. [in Ukrainian].

Rash W. (2011) Hyoid / Thyroid Fracture. Journal of Emergency Nursing. 37 (2): 182-183.

Stewart ME, Erath BD (2020) Investigating Blunt Force Trauma to the Larynx : the role of inferior-superior vocal fold displacement on phonation Journal of Biomechanics. 10: 1-28

Tachiev OV. (2018) Analiz sudebno-meditsinskih ekspertiz v sluchayah travm organov grudnoy kletki, oslozhnivshihsya malyim gemotoraksom pri ne smertelnyih sluchayah (DTP, padenii, razlichnyih fizicheskih vozdeystviyah) po dannyim otdela sudebno-meditsinskih ekspertiz poterpevshih, obvinyaemyih i drugih lits za 2013–2017 gg [Analysis of forensic examinations in cases of chest injuries complicated by small hemothorax in non-fatal cases (accidents , falls, various physical impacts) according to the department of forensic examinations of victims, accused and others for 2013-2017]. Zb-k m-lov: mezhdunarodnogo kongressa i nauchno-prakticheskoy shkolyi «Aktualnyie voprosyi sudebnoy meditsinyi i ekspertnoy praktiki – 2018»; 2018 aprel 18-20; M. s. 39. [in Russian].

Abakumov MM. (2013) Mnozhestvennyie i sochetannyie raneniya shei, grudi, zhivota [Multiple and combined injuries of the neck, chest, abdomen]. M .: Binom. 687 s. [in Russian].

Feng AL, Parikh A., Gadkaree SK, Naunheim MR, Song PC (2020) Laryngeal fractures in professional and semiprofessional ice hockey players. Laryngoscope Investigative Otolaryngology. 5: 1110 –1116.

Sethi RKV, Khatib D, Kligerman M, Kozin ED, Gray ST, Naunheim MR. (2019) Laryngeal fracture presentation and management in United States emergency rooms. Laryngoscope. 129 (10): 2341-2346.

Viejo-Moreno R, García-Fuentes C, Mudarra-Reche C, Terceros-Almanza LJ, Chico-Fernández M. (2019) Laryngeal injury in closed cervical traumatism . Med . Intensive. 43: 503-507.

Khodaee M, Waterbrook AL, Gammons M. (2020) Sports related fractures, dislocations and trauma. Switzerland Springer. 1020 p.

Ikonnikova DI, Tumanov EV. (2018) Sravnitelnyiy analiz meditsinskih kriteriev tyazhesti vreda, prichinennogo zdorovyu cheloveka pri zakryitoy travme organov grudnoy polosti v rossiyskoy federatsii i stranah postsovetskogo prostranstva [Comparative analysis of medical criteria for the severity of harm caused to human health in closed trauma of the thoracic cavity in the Russian Federation and the post-soviet space] Zb-k m-lov: mezhdunarodnogo kongressa i nauchno-prakticheskoy shkolyi «Aktualnyie voprosyi sudebnoy meditsinyi i ekspertnoy praktiki – 2018»; 2018 aprel 18-20; M. s. 33-34. [in Russian].

Kolkutin VV., Sosedko YuI. (2002) Sudebno-meditsinskaya ekspertiza povrezhdeniy u zhivyih lits [Forensic examination of injuries in living persons.]. M. s. 9-39. [in Russian].

Devyatkin AE, Vinnik NI, Chernyak VV. (2017) Sudebnaya meditsina: uchebn. posob [Forensic medicine: textbook]. Poltava: VGUZU «UMSA». 116 s. [in Russian].

Balci AE, Eren N, Eren Ş, Ülkü R. (2002) Surgical treatment of post-traumatic tracheobronchial injuries: 14-year experience. European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery. 22 (6): 984–989. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1010-7940(02)00591-2

Mercer SJ, Jones CP, Bridge M, Clitheroe E, Morton B, Groom P. (2016) Systematic review of the anesthetic management of non-iatrogenic acute adult airway trauma. British Journal of Anesthesia. 117 (S1): i49 – i59.

Copyright for articles published in the journal is regulated by the License Agreement for the use of a scientific article in the journal, which is concluded between the author of the article (Licensor) and Kharkov National Medical University (Licensee, publisher of the journal "Inter Collegas"). The licensor grants to the Licensee a non-exclusive non-exclusive license for the use of the article (a license that does not exclude the use of the article by the Licensor and the issuance of licenses to others for use of this article) on the terms and for the period specified in the contract. The licensor (the author of the article) grants the Licensee the right to reproduce the article (publication in the journal "Inter Collegas", publication, duplication, duplication or other reproduction of the article without limiting the circulation of copies, each copy of the article must contain the name of the Licensor; Of general information, including the publication of the article in full or in part on the Internet on the journal page, the right to use the metadata of the article (titles, full names of authors, annotations, bibliography eskih materials) through the dissemination and communication to the public, processing and systematization, as well as inclusion in various databases and in-formational system).

The licensor grants the licensee the right to transfer, store and process his personal data (full name, scientific degree, academic title, place of work and position, contact information of the authors) with the purpose of including them in the database in accordance with the Law of Ukraine No. 2297 - VI "on protection of personal data" from 01.06.2010.

Personal data and metadata of the article are provided for their storage and processing in various databases and information systems, including them in analytical and statistical reporting, creating sound relationships between the objects of works of science, literature and art with personal data, etc. on unlimited territory. The licensee has the right to transfer the specified data for processing and storage to third parties provided that such a fact is notified with the provision of information about the third party (name and address) to the Licensor.